chatgpt

[amarao]

Wow. 4-ка реально отжигает по сравнению с тройкой.

... можно я предположу, что ближайшим аналогом того, что сделают неронки с человечеством, будет изобретение письменности с уклоном в печатный станок?

До этого момента, знания надо было выслушивать. Потом их стало можно просто прочитать. После печатного станка - практически где угодно.

А после старта нейронок знания можно получать в контексте, то есть их больше не надо вычитывать.

У меня ощущение, что футуристы эту градацию не достаточно хорошо обсосали, и мы вывалились за границу фантастики. Все книги с "умными машинами" не объясняют этого нюанса, когда тебе дают ответ в контексте, как если бы ты с сеньёром в этой области беседовал.

Comments

[kondybas]

Все еще слабое звено - достоверность и релевантность реферативных "знаний", ибо нейросеть не понимает, о чем речь, а только лепит ассоциативный ответ на набор ключевых слов и словосочетаний по имеющемуся набору текстов.

Чтобы было понятнее:

Q: What was the motivation for dwarves to join the "Fellowship of the Ring"?

A: The Fellowship of the Ring, a group of nine members from different races of Middle-earth who joined together to destroy the One Ring and defeat Sauron.

The only dwarf in the Fellowship was Gimli, son of Glóin, who was a descendant of Durin the Deathless. Gimli was chosen to represent his people at the Council of Elrond, where he learned that his cousin Balin had perished in Moria. Gimli joined the Fellowship out of loyalty to his father and his king, Dáin II, who had refused to ally with Sauron. Gimli also wanted to avenge Balin and reclaim Moria for his kin.

Gimli was initially distrustful of elves, especially Legolas, who was from the same realm as the elves who had once imprisoned his father. However, as they journeyed together, Gimli and Legolas became close friends and fought side by side in many battles. Gimli also developed a deep admiration for Galadriel, the Lady of Lothlórien, and asked for a strand of her hair as a gift. She gave him three, which he treasured more than gold.


Короче, как Шура Балаганов, среагировав на ключевые слова, начал довольно толково, хотя и монотонно, пересказывать содержание массовой брошюры «Мятеж на Очакове», так и LM выдает "что первым на ум пришло".

[amarao]

Спрашивать надо уметь:

Q: What was the motivation for dwarves to join the "Fellowship of the Ring"? Why dwarves send Gimly at all?

The Fellowship of the Ring in J.R.R. Tolkien's "The Lord of the Rings" is made up of members from all the Free Peoples of Middle-Earth: Men, Elves, Hobbits, and Dwarves. The motivation for Dwarves, and specifically Gimli, to join the Fellowship stems from a few reasons:

Friendship and Alliance with Other Races: Gimli, the son of Glóin, represents the Dwarves in the Fellowship. He comes to the Council of Elrond as part of the delegation from the Lonely Mountain (Erebor) due to the friendship and alliance that was reestablished between the Dwarves and the Elves following the Battle of Five Armies in "The Hobbit." The alliance with Men, specifically the Dunedain, also exists from older times. The Dwarves joining the Fellowship is symbolic of the unity among the Free Peoples of Middle-earth in their common struggle against the Dark Lord Sauron.

The Threat to All of Middle-Earth: The Dwarves understand that if Sauron regains the One Ring, all of Middle-Earth, including their own kingdoms, is in peril. It's not just an altruistic gesture; it's also a matter of self-preservation. They have a vested interest in the Ring's destruction.

Gimli's Personal Motivation: Gimli has his personal motivations as well. He wishes to honor the commitment of his father, Glóin, one of the original members of Thorin Oakenshield's company. Gimli also develops a deep friendship with Legolas, a member of the Elven race, and their camaraderie is one of the highlights of the Fellowship's journey.

Messages from Mordor: At the Council of Elrond, Gimli's father, Glóin, tells about a messenger from Mordor who had come to Erebor asking about hobbits and offering the return of one of the seven dwarven rings in exchange for cooperation. This indicates the rising threat of Sauron and serves as a more immediate impetus for the dwarves to join the effort against him.

Sending Gimli, a brave and skilled warrior, was both a symbolic and practical choice for the Dwarves. His courage, loyalty, and prowess in battle proved to be valuable assets for the Fellowship in the trials they faced.

Лично по мне этот ответ куда более обширный, чем я сам могу дать.

[kondybas]

Чтобы задать правильный вопрос, нужно уже знать ответ :)

[amarao]

Нет, чтобы задавать правильный вопрос, нужно знать, что ты хочешь получить. Это не то же самое, что "знать ответ". Разница как между "заказать еду в ресторане" и "приготовить".